Do you think that belief in religions and gods will vanish completely sometime in the future?
That was around 1880.
*sigh* (John Hattan #1196)
I on the other hand, wish to join with my fellow optimists and opine that YES INDEED, RELIGION WILL VANISH. Why? Well, I look at the continuing exponential growth of techonological development as the key to humans transcending their physical realm. I can envision the day when we finally overcome death itself.
Either that, or we blow our selves to smithereens. Either way, there won't be religion. (Todd Adamson #1114)
Another factor that *could* have a great influence in people turning from religion would be a major scientific discovery such as an explanation of the universe' origin back to the very moment of the Big Bang, or the creation of artificial life. I know this wouldn't faze the True Believer's because they've ignored the Theory of Evolution for 150 years.
I don't think religion will ever die out because it fulfills a basic need for many people. There will always be a substantial portion of the population unwilling to decide for themselves how to live. They want *desperately* to be *told* how to act and think and feel everyone else should believe as they do. The security of being part of "the group" is overwhelmingly appealing to them. (Dennis Curran #1178)
Religion probably began as mankind began to seek answers for things it could not comprehend. Unfortunately, religion has become so past-centric that it refuses to accept new explanations for phenomenon when they are provided.
Most things locked in a stale state of non-change will die eventually, and if religion is to persist into the future, it will have to step by step accept the findings of modern science and adjust its views accordingly.
But first if must break its past-worshipping ideaology, and come into the present. The pick of the month in a bookclub I am in is a book called "Why Christianity Must Change or Die" by Bishop John Shelby Spong. It is about the fact that xianity is going to have to drop such concepts as heaven, hell, virgin birth, etc.... I have thought of ordering it just to see
what an xian bishop has to say on the subject. Here is a quote from the blurb on the book: "Traditional theism must be replaced with spiritual humanism. The church is no longer a law-giving institution but a community of faith and service. Heaven and Hell cease to be literal realities, but reminders that our actions have consequences.... a sobering concept for christians who persecute gays, marginalizw women, and use the doctrine to justify acts of violence." How long before this guy gets excommunicated
do ya think?
Religion will not die, but I think that in the long run it must change.... whether it will try to change for the better, or become an even uglier monster to resist such changes as above.... we will have to wait and see.
When I left the ministry and was struggling with coming to terms with
life without the concept of a sky-daddy... I began to attempt to live by
a personal philosophy that I felt helped me:
Heaven is becoming like that which you love, Hell is becoming like that which you hate.
The only question for theism and especially xianity is whether they will plunge deeper into "hell" by becoming an even more hypocritical philosophy, or whether they will attempt to give up the biblio-centric literalism that has kept them from aspiring to the true use of religion... by "the true use of religion" I refer to the original driving force behind birth of religion... a search for true answers.
The bible has kept them from aspiring to the only useful idea of "heaven" that religion has... the idea of finding real answers to mans oldest questions. (Mark House #1513)
OTOH, I have seen social major changes in behavior and attitudes in my lifetime. In the U.S., African Americans can now attend colleges from which they were previously denied admittance, litter along the highways
has been controlled, smoking has changed from a desirable trait to one
that is shunned, and women can now fly aircraft in combat. I don't mean
to imply that all instances of bigotry, discrimination or stupidity has been eradicated, but some things have actually improved.
I'm hopeful that more and more people will not need to view the world through veils or superstition nor need to explain it by referring to ancient myths. I don't expect to see a major change in my lifetime, but I'll do what I can to teach the children that the universe can be seen
in the magnificence that is reality. (Liz Huth #658)
I think the appeal in hoping that there's something bigger than humans
is too strong, too powerful. It's too comforting. I believe that as long
as there's human misery, close-brushes with death, war, victims of crime, survivors of airplane crashes, etc., there will be a belief in gods.
People who can't make sense of these things want to believe they are chosen. People who feel thankful for being alive want to believe a god chose them. Take religion and god from these people and they feel insignificant.
That covers the flock.
On the sheppard side of things, there's too many people who profit from selling gods and religion. There are a lot of people making a comfortable living selling their god weekly. And the power over the flock is a drug
to these people. Take religion and god away from these people and their livelihood and power over people goes away.
So, no, I don't think belief in gods or religion will ever go away.
I know it's a pessimistic way to view things. My only solaces is what my philosophy instructor
in college, Mr. Hann, used to say: "Pessimism is the only optimistic view of life". (Tony
Livernois #1440)
Click here to return to master question page.